GWR header image


 
Appeal banner

Latest Gotherington update


article by: Darren Fairley
posted on: 08 December 2010
updated on: 09 February 2011

/media/154106/01_thumb.jpg/media/154113/02_thumb.jpg/media/154120/03_thumb.jpg/media/154127/04_thumb.jpg/media/154134/05_thumb.jpg/media/154141/06_thumb.jpg/media/154148/07_thumb.jpg/media/154155/08_thumb.jpg/media/154162/09_thumb.jpg/media/154169/10_thumb.jpg/media/154176/11_thumb.jpg

Despite the best intentions, please accept my apologies for not updating on progress sooner.  The progress and findings on site has been quite significant indeed.

All of the Soil Nailing is now complete and the contractors are on their last push before the Christmas and New Year period.  The 'nail count' is roughly as follows:

Area 1 - 108
Area 3 - 88
Area 4 - 44
Area 5 - 57
Area 7 - 56

If you you have a look at the last update, 'each nail' takes a lot of effort and work and gives a good appreciation for what is now holding back thousands of tonnes of embankment and formation.

Areas 2 and 6 area the full excavation sections.  By the New Year it is anticipated that Area 2 which was the largest section to be completely removed will be complete as well. 

As programmed and normal practice test soil nails have been inserted and tested to ensure everything has gone in correctly and assumptions and calculations are correct and they have passed successfully.  From a financial point of view the test is extremely important; it has proved that the engineering solution was robust but not over specified - the nails have the strength that was predicted and importantly not to excess.  From a financial point of view not over specifying, is just as important as not under specifying - both in turn would have come with extra cost - (Hopefully that makes sense).  

To say the timing for all this nailing and meshing was favourable can not be underestimated given the snow that is now engulfing the country!

Thankfully the engineering assessments were absolutely 'on the money' in more ways than one.  So far there have been now unexpected surprises and before the poor weather set in the contractor was slightly ahead of schedule.  Allowance has been made for the winter period that the work will be undertaken in and we wait to see just how heavy the snow and icy conditions will bite.  What has been established is that the depth of the fracture did indeed reach to a full depth of 7m in places.  The diggers drew out the clay materials at the base of the slip it quite simply peeled off of the Ridge and Furrows below and a soil layer that had not been exposed for over 100 years.

Area 2 is now being filled and layered with strengthening material and a soil berm (basically and area extended out from the embankment giving extra mass and support to the higher sections).

The contractors looked at me quite strangely but then with some realisation when it was suggested that we could probably grow 100 year old grass from the soil!!!

In addition to the visible progress there have been a lot of other activities going on.  Preparation is now under way and being set up to excavate the second and smaller area Area 6 now that it the embankment either side has been treated with soil nails.  The to north and south of the slip the culverts have been CCTV surveyed and additional drainage cleared to ensure they remain clear and in good condition - whilst we have such good access it would be a shame to not add in the extra little bits that will make such a difference for the long term.

So what is next - well there is still a lot more to do.

Area 6 will be started first thing in the New Year and once this is complete effectively the last of the heavy engineering activities will have been talked.  Then the drainage out of the Malvern side of the embankment can be connected up.  This is two fold.  New drainage has been incorporated mid height in the embankment and this will feed into the last work which will be a new drain at the bottom of the embankment.

Last but not least, there is then the matter of final dressing of the embankment making sure all the meshing is complete and tied in, removing the access along the side of the track and restoring the field and decamping the contractors worksite and accommodation.

May I thank everyone for every single donation that has been made to the slip appeal, large or small.  We are making sure that every penny is well spent and invested prudently to ensure that continued operation of Your Railway.

Whilst we have now passed the point of no return on progress and where we could have stopped and suspended the contract had funds not been forthcoming, it is now extremely important that funds continue to be built up with our appeal donations, as previously notes large or small, regular or one off.  We are very, very grateful for your continued support and look forward to welcoming everyone back to Cheltenham Racecourse.






 

12 comments for “Gotherington update (1)”

  1. Gravatar of Chris MilneChris Milne
    Posted 08 December 2010 at 09:07:11

    Thanks Darren.
    The expertise, time and thought you have given to this project are extremely impressive. The results are looking equally impressive. Thank you to you and your team. It's a lot more than "Fairley" satisfactory!

    Keep up the great work!
    Chris



  2. Gravatar of AndyAndy
    Posted 08 December 2010 at 20:33:36

    Its good that this work is being done to such a high standard. It should safeguard the railway for many years from a similar problem at this location.

    However the other areas of concern on the railway cannot all be repaired at the same high cost. Are other solutions being considered that are more appropriate for Steam railway budgets ? What embankment work can be undertaken in house ?
    Clearly some repairs can be done by ourselves, as this has been done at much lower cost and successfully at other locations in the past (albeit while dealing with less serious slips).

    We simply don't have the money to fix three or four more locations to this standard if they aren't prevented from becoming critical. If the only solutions to be considered are to use Network Rail best practice, it could be game over for our railway very quickly. The original GWR did a pretty good job of fixing embankments without modern technology, consultants and high cost. I'd be interested to know what scope there is for us to replicate in house these sorts of repairs ?

    I suspect quite a few members are worried about the long term prospects of our line given the many clay embankments that could require repairs in the future.

  3. Gravatar of Darren FairleyDarren Fairley
    Posted 08 December 2010 at 22:28:03

    Andy has raised some very good points that I would like to answer in detail.

    Please rest assured that on the Board we share the concerns about the future of the railway and how we can best use the Donations that are coming in expressly for that purpose. I can’t reiterate enough though that we have to repair things properly and that the simple patching and making do of the past (BR) hasn’t stood a great test in some cases.

    Our Steam Railway Budget is extremely small and the large scale railways of the past had much more surplus material that they could and did use to best affect at the time. It needs to be considered that the railway wasn’t running and carrying load for the majority of the last 30-40 years or so since the original Gotherington repair was undertaken (at the very end of the BR life of the line) and that has to be taken into account when viewing its previous success or not.

    There are other areas, much less serious that have been repaired in the past and these are being monitored and re-looked at as part of the Appeal.
    For example, just one of the methods of holding repairs that was looked at at Gotherington and suggested internally and has been looked at on different areas of a different nature, is preloading or very basic mass stabilisation. We do not have a ready supply of material to drop into load the front edge of embankments should they start to strain (we don’t have the connections to bring in by rail either). Most importantly if the slip is of the type that we found at Gotherington loading alone would have made the situation worse. The Engineers that we have used are well used to working on Heritage Railways not just NR and have trimmed costs substantially to reflect our situation as best possible. There are a lot of other activities being planned and some will take place in the closed season with our own resources at a very intense level and pace.

    We might be a historical railway but we do not operate in an historic age we have to act in a responsible manner and consultants and engineers are only engaged where we do not have the fully qualified resources within. The embankments are much older and much more tired and need a different kind of repair and maintenance than historically. If something can be done in house it has and will continue to be done in house – we are assessing and tackling those areas we can do as part of the appeal.

    As far as future repairs to clay embankments, we can never be sure that we will have assessed every eventuality but at least we have the opportunity now by hitting the worst areas, to leave the smaller repairs to internal resources when and if appropriate.

    We will safeguard the railway for future generations. The appeal funds are the backbone of this and we look forward to moving back to Cheltenham with a healthier railway.

  4. Gravatar of John GilbertJohn Gilbert
    Posted 09 December 2010 at 10:53:27

    I, too, should like to thank Darren for his very full explanation of ongoing activity at Gotherington, and also for his detailed answers to the more general and long-term worries/queries posed by Andy. It is very interesting as well as being a great relief to know all that is being done, but also the awareness you have of future problems; I have myself often thought of the lengthy stretches of clay embankments you have on the GWSR. It is a pity that you are not yet near enough to Honeybourne to envisage a main line connection there by which equipment/materials could be brought on to the GWSR line. One day perhaps.....

  5. Gravatar of Nick JonesNick Jones
    Posted 09 December 2010 at 11:23:25

    Thanks for a valuable insight into the works and discussion of the difficulties wihich might crop-up in future. Impressive.

  6. Gravatar of Rob PryceRob Pryce
    Posted 09 December 2010 at 15:30:59

    Thank you, Darren, for your most comprehensive report. It appears that the money available is being used to very good effect. Living, as I do, 140 miles away from the railway, it is a vital source of information about progress. I will be there on the 29/30th of December.(Weather permitting!),to see work at first hand.

  7. Gravatar of David FrenchDavid French
    Posted 10 December 2010 at 09:40:10

    Under the current rate of progress what is the estimated start date for the relaying of the track ? That is assuming that there are no hold ups, like a spell of bad weather in the new year for example, to put the schedule back.

  8. Gravatar of Darren FairleyDarren Fairley
    Posted 10 December 2010 at 10:34:48

    David, good question and I held back from giving the date as when writing up the update, whilst we were ahead on programme, the snow was starting to hit the country.

    We are looking to formally make an announcement very soon and hope to do so on the next update if not before.

  9. Gravatar of David FrenchDavid French
    Posted 10 December 2010 at 12:18:41

    Thanks for the quick reply Darren. I await the announcement with interest.

  10. Gravatar of Andy BryneAndy Bryne
    Posted 11 December 2010 at 07:58:08

    Can I add my thanks to Darren for this very comprehensive update. I do hope that we don't get a repeat of the dreadful weather we have had over the last 3 weeks (the snow is only just starting to melt here in the East Midlands) and that progress can continue to be made, both on the Gotherington work and on the extension through Laverton to Broadway. AS John Gilbert said, it is a pity that the Honeybourne connection wasn't already there as this would at least allow material in by rail (as per the WSR and the Bluebell - in the last example extraction too!) but I believe that won't be too long in coming. Many thanks for the update and photos.

  11. Gravatar of Mike daviesMike davies
    Posted 11 December 2010 at 18:34:45

    As a race-goer I have been meaning for some weeks to find out why I have not seen any trains this season. Thank you are the detailed information (and photos). Fingers crossed for the Gold Cup.

  12. Gravatar of Bill BlakeBill Blake
    Posted 27 December 2010 at 13:08:19

    I am very impressed with what those who are restoring the embankment have achieved. It is hugely encouraging to see our railway being returned to the condition it was before the slip took place. My thanks are offered for all this hard work.


Comment on this item